Weblogic Authors: Yeshim Deniz, Elizabeth White, Michael Meiner, Michael Bushong, Avi Rosenthal

Blog Feed Post

Controls are still an issue for the PCI Tokenization Guidelines

The PCI Council today released the long-awaited tokenization guidelines (Information Supplement: PCI Tokenization Guidelines) which give merchants specific guidance on using tokenization to reduce PCI scope and assessment costs, which have been costing large merchants upwards of $500,000 / year.

While the guidance is strong, it seems to provide one area of ambiguity around controls for so called high-value tokens which we will examine in some depth later in this blog. First, let’s dig into the guidance itself:

Out of Scope Considerations

The main thrust of the guidance defines a scoping principle and then out-of-scope considerations. The scoping principles state that all components of the tokenization system are considered part of the cardholder data envrionment (CDE). The scoping principles refine this further to include the token generation and detokenization components as well as any system with access to the tokenization system or part of the CDE.

For specific out-of-scope considerations, the document states the following requirements. I thought it would be helpful to analyze the guidelines in terms of a real-world use case: credit card information stored in a data-warehouse application used for post-payment customer loyalty tracking. Let’s assume that our fictional merchant has decided to receive new entries as format-preserving tokens using Intel(R) Expressway Tokenization Broker (ETB). In this example, the gateway is the tokenization engine and is the only entity with access to a secure token vault. We can assume that the data-warehouse application has no need for the live PANs and if PAN data is required for charge-back or refunds, it is retrieved by a different application (which would be in full PCI scope).

  1. Recovery of the PAN value associated with a token must not be computationally feasible through knowledge of only the token, multiple tokens, or other token-to-PAN combinations.
  2. ETB generates format-preserving tokens based on true random numbers or pseudo-random numbers with a protected seed. This means that there is no mathematical relation between the token and the PAN. This requirement appears to be met. It is interesting to note here that the guidance would technically allow a token generated from the PAN through an encryption or hash function to count, but the burden would be to show that this transformation is computationally infeasible to reverse

  3. PAN cannot be retrieved even if the token and the systems it resides on are compromised
  4. Expressway Tokenization Broker (ETB) stores PAN values encrypted in the secure token vault using AES-256. Even if the vault were compromised, the attacker would have to execute a brute-force attack against AES-256. The same goes with the data-warehouse application as only tokens would be available. Gaining access to only the token list would provide no value as well as there is no mathematical relation between the two. Note that again, this may not be the case when the token is generated using an encryption or hash function.

  5. System components are segmented (isolated) from any application, system, process, or user with: (i) The ability to submit a de-tokenization request for that token and retrieve the PAN, (ii) Access to the tokenization system, data vault, or cryptographic keys for that token, (iii) Access to token input data or other information that can be used to de-tokenize or derive the PAN value from the token
  6. ETB supports both the proper segmentation and access control. In our example, the broker would be sending tokens to the data-warehouse application rather than live PANs and would be segmented by at least one network hop. Further, the broker would not provide de-tokenization access to the data-warehouse application using a specific security policy. The broker itself is also segmented from the secure vault and only the broker can access the vault using 2-way protected TLS communication. Further, an external identity store such as LDAP, Active Directory, Siteminder, Oracle Access Manager, IBM Tivoli Access Manager and others can be used to authenticate de-tokenization requests. A requesting application can approach the broker through an authenticated REST or SOAP API call to retrieve a token or provide an entire document or message to be tokenized.

  7. System components are not connected to the tokenization system or processes, including the data vault, or cryptographic key storage
  8. Here, the system component (data-warehouse application) would only have the ability to receive tokens from ETB and would not be connected to the tokenization or de-tokenization process and would not have access to the vault or cryptogrpahic key storage. It is an open question if this ability to receive only tokens will be classified as connectedness.

  9. System components do not store, process, or transmit cardholder data or sensitive authentication data through any other channel
  10. This item would be met by our example as the data-warehouse application would only be receiving format-preserving tokens.

  11. System components that previously stored, processed, or transmitted cardholder data prior to implementation of the tokenization solution have been examined to ensure that all traces of cardholder data have been securely deleted.

  12. This is more of a process issue. It makes sense that before our data-warehouse application can be taken out of scope, the existing PAN data must be thoroughly scrubbed out

It seems that the key issue turns on network connectedness. In other words, if by virtue of network connection only, if the data warehouse application is still in scope even though it is (a) receiving only tokens, and (b) has no access to exchange tokens for PANs, then a QSA should be able to make this distinction without a full review of the data-warehouse application and all of its connected components.

High-Value Tokens

Section four of the PCI Tokenization guidelines poses an interesting question regarding high value tokens. Just what is a high-value token? Here, they are referring to tokens that can be used to generate transactions. While they are not themselves PAN values, they can be used as a true surrogate for the PAN. The intuitive example given is the use of a room number in paying for a meal at a hotel restaurant. In this example, the token (the room number) along with a last name (ostensibly a secret) generates a transaction for a credit card. Under this view, the PCI council seems to be suggesting that a list of compromised last names and room numbers falls under PCI DSS! In other words, if tokens begin to look like and act like PANs, they bear the same compliance burden PANs. This seems like overstretching and more clarity is needed.

Fortunately, the guidelines give an additional caveat, which is the the key phrase, “additional controls” , and this is where more guidance is needed. In other words, the loss or compromise of a token doesn’t expose anything, as long as you have the proper controls. What could these controls look like? It seems reasonable that tokens that work just like PANs – let’s called them uncontrolled high value tokens – definitely contribute to the risk of a breach. Here is a stab at some types of controls for high value tokens that generate transactions.

High Value Token Controls

  • Single-Use: Should be single-use where one token maps to a different PAN each time. This may reduce the risk of an attacker collecting tokens for a concentrated attack in the future

  • Short Lifetime: Should be given a constrained lifetime for additional protection
  • Authentication: Should only generate a transaction in connection with additional protected authentication data that defines the entity attempting to make the transaction (person or system)
  • Authorization: Is only authorized for a specific transaction and not others.
  • Unpredictability : Valid tokens should not be predictable. In other words, an attacker should not be able to anticipate valid token values

The previous list is just a stab. It will be interesting to see what sort of specific guidance emerges in the future.


Read the original blog entry...

More Stories By Application Security

This blog references our expert posts on application and web services security.

@ThingsExpo Stories
Rodrigo Coutinho is part of OutSystems' founders' team and currently the Head of Product Design. He provides a cross-functional role where he supports Product Management in defining the positioning and direction of the Agile Platform, while at the same time promoting model-based development and new techniques to deliver applications in the cloud.
Business professionals no longer wonder if they'll migrate to the cloud; it's now a matter of when. The cloud environment has proved to be a major force in transitioning to an agile business model that enables quick decisions and fast implementation that solidify customer relationships. And when the cloud is combined with the power of cognitive computing, it drives innovation and transformation that achieves astounding competitive advantage.
IoT is rapidly becoming mainstream as more and more investments are made into the platforms and technology. As this movement continues to expand and gain momentum it creates a massive wall of noise that can be difficult to sift through. Unfortunately, this inevitably makes IoT less approachable for people to get started with and can hamper efforts to integrate this key technology into your own portfolio. There are so many connected products already in place today with many hundreds more on the h...
In his session at Cloud Expo, Alan Winters, U.S. Head of Business Development at MobiDev, presented a success story of an entrepreneur who has both suffered through and benefited from offshore development across multiple businesses: The smart choice, or how to select the right offshore development partner Warning signs, or how to minimize chances of making the wrong choice Collaboration, or how to establish the most effective work processes Budget control, or how to maximize project result...
Personalization has long been the holy grail of marketing. Simply stated, communicate the most relevant offer to the right person and you will increase sales. To achieve this, you must understand the individual. Consequently, digital marketers developed many ways to gather and leverage customer information to deliver targeted experiences. In his session at @ThingsExpo, Lou Casal, Founder and Principal Consultant at Practicala, discussed how the Internet of Things (IoT) has accelerated our abilit...
In his keynote at 19th Cloud Expo, Sheng Liang, co-founder and CEO of Rancher Labs, discussed the technological advances and new business opportunities created by the rapid adoption of containers. With the success of Amazon Web Services (AWS) and various open source technologies used to build private clouds, cloud computing has become an essential component of IT strategy. However, users continue to face challenges in implementing clouds, as older technologies evolve and newer ones like Docker c...
Data is the fuel that drives the machine learning algorithmic engines and ultimately provides the business value. In his session at Cloud Expo, Ed Featherston, a director and senior enterprise architect at Collaborative Consulting, discussed the key considerations around quality, volume, timeliness, and pedigree that must be dealt with in order to properly fuel that engine.
No hype cycles or predictions of zillions of things here. IoT is big. You get it. You know your business and have great ideas for a business transformation strategy. What comes next? Time to make it happen. In his session at @ThingsExpo, Jay Mason, Associate Partner at M&S Consulting, presented a step-by-step plan to develop your technology implementation strategy. He discussed the evaluation of communication standards and IoT messaging protocols, data analytics considerations, edge-to-cloud tec...
In his keynote at 18th Cloud Expo, Andrew Keys, Co-Founder of ConsenSys Enterprise, provided an overview of the evolution of the Internet and the Database and the future of their combination – the Blockchain. Andrew Keys is Co-Founder of ConsenSys Enterprise. He comes to ConsenSys Enterprise with capital markets, technology and entrepreneurial experience. Previously, he worked for UBS investment bank in equities analysis. Later, he was responsible for the creation and distribution of life settl...
In his session at @ThingsExpo, Dr. Robert Cohen, an economist and senior fellow at the Economic Strategy Institute, presented the findings of a series of six detailed case studies of how large corporations are implementing IoT. The session explored how IoT has improved their economic performance, had major impacts on business models and resulted in impressive ROIs. The companies covered span manufacturing and services firms. He also explored servicification, how manufacturing firms shift from se...
IoT is at the core or many Digital Transformation initiatives with the goal of re-inventing a company's business model. We all agree that collecting relevant IoT data will result in massive amounts of data needing to be stored. However, with the rapid development of IoT devices and ongoing business model transformation, we are not able to predict the volume and growth of IoT data. And with the lack of IoT history, traditional methods of IT and infrastructure planning based on the past do not app...
Organizations planning enterprise data center consolidation and modernization projects are faced with a challenging, costly reality. Requirements to deploy modern, cloud-native applications simultaneously with traditional client/server applications are almost impossible to achieve with hardware-centric enterprise infrastructure. Compute and network infrastructure are fast moving down a software-defined path, but storage has been a laggard. Until now.
Digital Transformation is much more than a buzzword. The radical shift to digital mechanisms for almost every process is evident across all industries and verticals. This is often especially true in financial services, where the legacy environment is many times unable to keep up with the rapidly shifting demands of the consumer. The constant pressure to provide complete, omnichannel delivery of customer-facing solutions to meet both regulatory and customer demands is putting enormous pressure on...
The best way to leverage your CloudEXPO | DXWorldEXPO presence as a sponsor and exhibitor is to plan your news announcements around our events. The press covering CloudEXPO | DXWorldEXPO will have access to these releases and will amplify your news announcements. More than two dozen Cloud companies either set deals at our shows or have announced their mergers and acquisitions at CloudEXPO. Product announcements during our show provide your company with the most reach through our targeted audienc...
DXWorldEXPO LLC announced today that All in Mobile, a mobile app development company from Poland, will exhibit at the 22nd International CloudEXPO | DXWorldEXPO. All In Mobile is a mobile app development company from Poland. Since 2014, they maintain passion for developing mobile applications for enterprises and startups worldwide.
"Akvelon is a software development company and we also provide consultancy services to folks who are looking to scale or accelerate their engineering roadmaps," explained Jeremiah Mothersell, Marketing Manager at Akvelon, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 21st Cloud Expo, held Oct 31 – Nov 2, 2017, at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA.
JETRO showcased Japan Digital Transformation Pavilion at SYS-CON's 21st International Cloud Expo® at the Santa Clara Convention Center in Santa Clara, CA. The Japan External Trade Organization (JETRO) is a non-profit organization that provides business support services to companies expanding to Japan. With the support of JETRO's dedicated staff, clients can incorporate their business; receive visa, immigration, and HR support; find dedicated office space; identify local government subsidies; get...
The current age of digital transformation means that IT organizations must adapt their toolset to cover all digital experiences, beyond just the end users’. Today’s businesses can no longer focus solely on the digital interactions they manage with employees or customers; they must now contend with non-traditional factors. Whether it's the power of brand to make or break a company, the need to monitor across all locations 24/7, or the ability to proactively resolve issues, companies must adapt to...
"We view the cloud not as a specific technology but as a way of doing business and that way of doing business is transforming the way software, infrastructure and services are being delivered to business," explained Matthew Rosen, CEO and Director at Fusion, in this SYS-CON.tv interview at 18th Cloud Expo (http://www.CloudComputingExpo.com), held June 7-9 at the Javits Center in New York City, NY.
DXWorldEXPO LLC announced today that the upcoming DXWorldEXPO | CloudEXPO New York event will feature 10 companies from Poland to participate at the "Poland Digital Transformation Pavilion" on November 12-13, 2018.